Get smart curated videos delivered to your inbox.   SUBSCRIBE
The Kid Should See This

The Fire Crystal Riddle and proof by contradiction

Watch more with these video collections:

Someone has tripped the magical alarms in the Element Temple. When you and the other monks arrive on the scene, you know you have a disaster on your hands. Four young apprentices broke into the temple’s inner chamber to steal the sacred element crystals. But when the alarm went off they panicked, and each of them swallowed a crystal. Can you determine who ate which crystal?

Everything changed when the fire crystal got stolen: Stop the video at 1m38s to try and solve the puzzle. Use the info below:

This TED-Ed puzzle can be solved by something called “proof by contradiction” or indirect proof, the method of figuring out what’s true by determining that it can’t be false. From

When proving something is true using proof by contradiction, you assume the statement to be false, and as you proceed with the proof, you run into a contradiction, making the assumption of your original statement being false impossible, thus it must be true.

When deciding if proof by contradiction is the best way to prove a given statement, it is a good idea to ask yourself, what would happen if the statement weren’t true?

Related reading: Reductio ad absurdum from Kiddle’s Kpedia and Proof by Contradiction at

Try these TED-Ed puzzlers on TKSST next:
• Can you solve the troll’s paradox riddle?
• Can you solve the penniless pilgrim riddle?
• Can you solve the virus riddle?
• Can you solve the time travel riddle?

This Webby award-winning video collection exists to help teachers, librarians, and families spark kid wonder and curiosity. TKSST features smarter, more meaningful content than what's usually served up by YouTube's algorithms, and amplifies the creators who make that content.

Curated, kid-friendly, independently-published. Support this mission by becoming a sustaining member today.